The Creepy Quad Cities Legend of the Banshee of Brady Street

The legend begins in 1918, when a man named Alfred Schadt supposedly moved his family into a grand Victorian home on Brady Street in Davenport.

Not long after the family moved in, tragedy struck: Schadt's young son died after falling from an attic window onto an iron fence below.

Some versions of the tale add an even darker twist, claiming a mysterious drifter was inside the house and may have pushed the boy.

And that was supposedly only the beginning.

Canva/Google Maps

 The Gangster, The Brothel, and The Strange Noises

The legend takes another turn when the supposedly tragic home is said to have sat empty for a long time before being purchased by a Chicago gangster.

According to the story, the gangster turned the grand house into a brothel. At first, business was good. But eventually, people supposedly began noticing things they couldn't explain.

Shadows moved when nobody was nearby. Objects seemed to shift on their own. And then there were the unsettling moaning sounds coming from inside the house.

Eventually, the business reportedly closed, and the building was left empty once again.

The Banshee Makes Her Appearance

Later, the house supposedly became a rooming house for college students.

That's when the haunting was said to return.

Residents reportedly described phantom footsteps moving through empty hallways, shadows drifting past doorways, and objects moving without anyone touching them. But the most frightening figure of all was the banshee.

In Irish folklore, a banshee is a supernatural woman whose mournful wail is believed to warn that someone is about to die. She's not necessarily the one who causes the death; her cry is an omen that death is near.

In the Brady Street legend, the banshee supposedly appeared as a ghostly woman whose presence terrified the students living in the house. Eventually, the story goes, they couldn't take it anymore and moved out.

Getty Images

What Happened To The House?

According to the legend, the house sat abandoned for years, gradually falling into disrepair before eventually being demolished.

Some versions say that when the house was torn down, its spirits were released into the city, including the banshee herself.

Legend has it that the banshee still wanders Brady Street and the surrounding area. Sometimes late at night, you can still hear her screams.

Is the Legend True?

John Brassard Jr., a Quad Cities historian and co-author of Eerie Quad Cities, investigated the legend and found no evidence that an Alfred Schadt lived on Brady Street at the time of the alleged events. Researchers also found no record of anyone by that name dying in Davenport between 1917 and 1920.

The Banshee of Brady Street is best understood as a local urban legend, a creepy story that combines a tragic child, a gangster's mansion, unexplained noises, and an Irish death omen.

Halloween Ball 2026

READ MORE: You're Invited To The Halloween Costume Ball At MVF